Ex parte PEYMAN - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1998-0308                                                        
          Application 07/844,879                                                      


          (2) the laser beam and coagulation limitations in claim 11,                 
          (3) the laser beam limitations in claim 15, (4) the                         
          sequential, incremental cornea portion removal limitations in               
          claim 25, (5) the sequential, incremental cornea portion                    
          removal and laser energy limitations in claim 26, and (6) the               
          laser beam and sequential, incremental cornea portion ablation              
          and removal limitations in claim 27.  The examiner’s reliance               
          on L’Esperance ‘608, L’Esperance ‘541, L’Esperance ‘913, Bath               
          and/or Peyman to overcome these deficiencies is not well                    
          taken.                                                                      


               L’Esperance ‘608 discloses a non-invasive surgical                     
          procedure wherein laser energy is used to remove cataractous                
          lens tissue from an eye without damaging the cornea or retina.              
                                                                                     


               L’Esperance ‘541 discloses a carbon dioxide laser probe                
          which can be used to contact, vaporize and remove various                   
          surface portions of an eye including cataract, iris, scleral,               
          corneal and vitreous tissues.                                               


                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007