Ex parte STEINMETZ et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1998-0402                                                        
          Application No. 08/490,046                                                  
               surface of the stepped recess . . . .                                  
          For this teaching, the examiner looks to Kunnecke, taking the               
          position that an indicator means located in a stepped recess                
          is taught by Kunnecke, and it would have been obvious to add                
          such a feature to the Sturm structure “for the purpose of                   
          preventing an overflow of thermoplastic material and limiting               
          the extension of the indicator beyond the sleeve” (Answer,                  
          page 4).                                                                    
               The thermoplastic pipe connector sleeve disclosed by                   
          Kunnecke is equipped with a recess (14) that has a narrowed                 
          opening (19) at its open end.  However, the Kunnecke indicator              
          is much different in structure and operation from that of                   
          Sturm.  It comprises a piston (17) located inwardly in the                  
          recess and a stem (18) mounted on the piston.  The piston is                
          larger than the opening at the top of the recess, and the stem              
          is small enough to                                                          




          be movable through it; thus, while the stem advances radially               
          outward when the piston moves under the pressure of the heated              
          thermoplastic material, the piston is precluded from exiting                
          the recess.  The piston and stem are not integral with the                  
                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007