Ex parte WILKEY - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1999-0114                                                        
          Application No. 08/656,286                                                  

          11 further requires that the bond produced by the adhesive is               
          such that “the bonded end edge, or edges, of said wrapper is                
          able to be peeled off for separating said products.”  As read               
          in light of appellant’s specification (see, for example, page               
          1, lines 30-33, and page 4, lines 6-10), we understand this                 
          claim terminology as requiring that the bond produced by the                
          adhesive is such that it fails before the material of the                   
          wrapper tears when an attempt is made to remove the wrapper by              
          lifting a bonded end edge of the wrapper.  In that the                      
          pressure sensitive adhesive coatings 14, 15 of Weiss produce                
          an immediate and highly effective bond when overlapped in                   
          pressure sensitive contact (column 2, lines 65-68), and firmly              
          unite the individual items with each other so that they in                  
          effect constitute a single unit (column 12, lines 39-41), and               
          secure the individual items together so that, in effect, they               
          can only be separated by breaking the band (column 3, lines                 
          45-47), it is, at best, speculative to consider the adhesive                
          of Weiss as being capable of producing a bond of the type                   
          called in claim 11 (i.e., so that the bonded end edges of the               
          band 10 are able of being peeled off for separating the                     
          individual items).  Accordingly, we hold that claim 11                      

                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007