Ex parte HOFMANN - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1999-2539                                       Page 6           
          Application No. 08/328,895                                                  


          comprising at least one conductor having opposite ends adapted              
          for connection to an electrical power source and at least one               
          turn forming a coil intermediate the ends."                                 


               After reviewing the entire teachings of the applied prior              
          art, we find ourselves in agreement with the appellant (brief,              
          pp. 5-10) that even if the prior art were combined in the                   
          manner set forth in the rejection under appeal it would not                 
          provide the claimed invention.  In that regard, the combined                
          teachings of the applied prior art do not teach or suggest "an              
          induction coil comprising at least one conductor having                     
          opposite ends adapted for connection to an electrical power                 
          source and at least one turn forming a coil intermediate the                
          ends" as recited in the claims under appeal.  The examiner's                
          position that this induction coil limitation is met by the                  
          electrodes disclosed in the applied prior art is without merit              
          for the reasons provided by the appellant in his brief.                     
          Moreover, it is abundantly clear that the electrodes disclosed              
          in the applied prior art are not formed by "at least one                    
          conductor having opposite ends adapted for connection to an                 
          electrical power source."                                                   







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007