JEON et al. V. CUPPS et al. - Page 30




          Interference No. 104,241                                                    



          the facts                                                                   
          in the record.  Specifically, Jeon et al. requested that,                   
          pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 1.607, an interference be declared                  
          with Cupps et al. (see Paper Number 10).  The very rule under               
          which Jeon et al. requested an interference requires that the               
          party requesting the interference present a proposed count,                 
          present at least one claim in their involved application                    
          corresponding to the count and identify at least one claim in               
          the patent with whom the party seeks an interference which                  
          corresponds to the count. See 37 C.F.R. § 1.607(a).                         
               It is clear from a review of Jeon et al.'s original                    
          submission that Jeon et al. intended to file and actually                   
          filed their showing under 37 C.F.R. § 1.608(b), not 37 C.F.R §              
          1.608(a) as argued by Jeon et al.  It is also clear that,                   
          contrary to Jeon et al.'s argument that they did not know what              
          the count in the interference would be, Jeon et al. proposed a              
          count in their original showing, as required by the rule,                   
          which proposed count was identical to Jeon et al.'s claim 29.               
          Claim 14 of Cupps et al. patent was said by Jeon et al. in                  
          their original showing to correspond exactly to the count                   
          proposed by them.                                                           

                                         30                                           








Page:  Previous  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007