CRAGG et al. V. MARTIN V. FOGARTY et al. - Page 4




          Interference No. 104,192                                                    
          Cragg v. Martin v. Fogarty                                                  

          order to show cause why judgment should not be entered against              
          Cragg.  Party Cragg requested final hearing for review of the               
          Board’s decision on Cragg’s preliminary motions 1 and 2 and on              
          Fogarty’s preliminary motion 12.  According to party Cragg it               
          should not have been made a junior party and thus need not                  
          have had to put on a priority case in the first instance.                   
          Party Fogarty requested review of the Board’s decision on its               
          preliminary motions 8 and 10.  Oral argument was made on                    
          February 28, 2001, before administrative patent judges                      
          Schafer, Lee and Medley.                                                    
                                  Findings of Fact                                    
               The below-listed findings as well as those contained in                
          the discussion portion of this opinion are supported by a                   
          preponderance of the evidence:                                              
               1.   This interference was declared on April 23, 1998,                 
          between three parties, Martin, Fogarty, and Goicoechea (now                 
          Cragg).                                                                     
               2.   The involved patent of Martin is Patent No.                       
          5,575,817, based on application 08/293,541, filed August 19,                
          1994.                                                                       
               3.   The involved application of Cragg is application                  

                                        - 4 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007