Appeal No. 2000-1917 Application 09/076,863 The invention relates to “a heat exchanger employed for exchanging heat between two fluids, for example, one fluid, that is a strong acidic or a strong alkaline medical fluid employed in an Integrated Circuit production line (i.e., IC production line) inside a clean room ... and another fluid, that is a heat transfer medium” (specification, page 1). Representative claim 1 reads as follows: 1. A fluororesin heat exchanger employed in a clean room for an IC circuit producing line, comprising: a plurality of resin tubes for mutually exchanging heat between a fluid flowing through an inside of the heat exchanger and a fluid flowing through an outside thereof; and a holding plate having plural independent tube holding holes, wherein: said plural resin tubes have ends respectively arranged at said plural independent tube holding holes of said holding plate, a longitudinally predetermined length of said resin tube from each end of said plural resin tubes being integrally fused into said holding plate; said holding plate has ring-spaces for emitting heat, respectively located around a periphery of each resin tube, except a fusing portion for fusing each end of said resin tubes into said holding plate; a diameter of each tube holding hole is almost the same as an external diameter of the end of each resin tube; and an outer end face of said holding plate and an end face of said resin tube having each end arranged at the tube holding hole at the same level. THE PRIOR ART The items relied on by the examiner as evidence of obviousness are: 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007