RIGGINS et al v. HOLSTEN et al - Page 61



          Interference 103,685                                                          
               thereof, or blends thereof which has been dyed with a                    
               mixture of a carrier and a dye soluble or dispersed                      
               in a dyebath, the carrier comprising an N-substituted                    
               aromatic carbonamide or an N,N-disubstituted aromatic                    
               carbonamide or mixture thereof.                                          
               The evidence of record establishes, and it is undisputed by              
          Holsten, that “Nomex” is a fibrous material formed from fibers of             
          an aromatic polyamide fiber.  See findings 14 and 16-20 in                    
          Holsten’s Opening Brief (HB, pp. 7-11).  It being undisputed that             
          “Nomex” is formed from fibers of an aromatic polyamide fiber, we              
          proceed to consider the merits of Riggins’ case for priority of               
          the invention of Count 2.                                                     
               We conclude from the evidence submitted by Riggins that                  
          Riggins actually reduced to practice an embodiment meeting all                
          the limitations of the invention defined by Claim 1 or Claim 43               
          of Holsten’s involved application, which correspond to Count 2,               
          no later than February 26, 1990, most certainly no later than                 
          March 22, 1990.  In particular, we find that Riggins’ evidence,               
          especially Riggins’ Notebook 1664, page 28 (signed by Howell                  
          Riggins on February 26, 1990), page 29 (signed by Howell Riggins              
          on March 22, 1990), and page 31 (signed by Howell Riggins on                  
          February 26, 1990 (RX 22), and the letter from H. Riggins to                  
          B. Triplett stamp-dated no later than February 27, 1990,                      
          entitled “Dye Promoters for Nomex” (RX 26), show that Riggins                 
          (1) contacted Nomex fabric (10.83 grams), a fibrous material                  
                                         -61-                                           




Page:  Previous  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007