RIGGINS et al v. HOLSTEN et al - Page 62



          Interference 103,685                                                          
          formed from fibers of an aromatic polyamide fiber, with a dyebath             
          comprising a mixture of N,N-diethyl benzamide (4 gms) and Acid                
          Blue #62 (2%owf) for 11/2 hrs at 265O F., cooled and dropped the               
          dyebath from the fabric, and washed and dried Nomex fabric                    
          colored “80% full (not as deep as dibutyl formamide)” (RX 22,                 
          p. 29) no later than February 26, 1990, most certainly no later               
          than March 22, 1990, and (2) contemporaneously appreciated that               
          the process he recorded on page 29 of Notebook 1664 effectively               
          dyed Nomex fabric.                                                            
               Having reviewed all the evidence of record, we conclude that             
          Riggins has established by a preponderance of the evidence of                 
          record that it actually reduced to practice an embodiment of                  
          Count 2, particularly an embodiment defined by Claim 1 or                     
          Claim 43 of Holsten’s involved application, before the earliest               
          date Holsten has shown that it reduced to practice and/or                     
          conceived of the same invention.  We determined above that                    
          Holsten’s evidence can establish conception of the invention of               
          Count 2 no earlier than March 26, 1990, and reduction of an                   
          embodiment of Count 2 to practice no later than April 10, 1990.               
          Riggins’ evidence, even when considered in a light most favorable             
          to Holsten, establishes that Riggins reduced an embodiment of                 
          Count 2 to practice no later than March 22, 1990.                             


                                         -62-                                           




Page:  Previous  55  56  57  58  59  60  61  62  63  64  65  66  67  68  69  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007