Appeal No. 1997-3701 11 Application No. 08/141,457 the claimed subject matter. See page 7. The compounds are described as improving the stability of organic coloring materials against light. See page 6. They are added to photographic image forming dyes and couplers including magenta couplers. See page 13. The magenta couplers include 5-pyrazolone compounds. See page 14, 16 and 17. The sulfur containing stabilizers designated as A-1 to A-29, page 10-11 are added to magenta dye layers and are further described as antifading agents. See pages 29-31 and 35. Lok discloses a color photographic element having a magenta dye forming coupler comprising a latent image stabilizer compound of the invention. See column 7, lines 52- 65. The compounds disclosed include heterocyclic organic compounds having sulfur as one of the hetero atoms and accordingly fall within the scope of the claimed subject matter wherein, “R and R may together form a ring including the sulfur atom.” See8 9 Abstract, and column 2, line 36-68. The sulfur containing compounds are exemplified by Compounds B and C and K and L. See column 4, lines 17-33 and column 5, lines 25-39. Fuseya discloses a development inhibitor precursor containing the requisite sulfide group. See Abstract, column 1, lines 61-62, and column 2, lines 17-60, column 3, line 4 to column 4, line 15. The compounds are present in photographic elements. See column 2, lines 64-68 and column 6, lines 40-53. Fuseya further discloses that thePage: Previous 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007