Ex parte TUMA et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 1998-1119                                                        
          Application No. 08/482,924                                                  


          bits do not agree, then the data is subjected to error                      
          correction.                                                                 
               In the error detection scheme disclosed by Knauft, a                   
          stored word is read immediately after it is stored (Abstract).              
          According to Knauft (column 3, lines 20 through 26), each word              
          that is stored is accompanied by a parity bit and a marking                 
          bit which indicates whether the word was stored in inverted                 
          form or not.  “When the word is read later on, it is again                  
          inverted by virtue of the marking in the additional storage                 
          element to retrieve the original correct information supplied”              
          (Abstract).                                                                 
               Based upon the teachings of Burghard and Knauft, the                   
          examiner is of the opinion (answer, page 5) that “it would                  
          have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art to               
          correct Burghard’s parity bit detected error by Knauft’s                    
          method as suggested by both of them so that error free data                 
          can be obtained from defective memory locations.”                           
               Appellants argue (brief, page 17) that:                                
               Thus, Applicants store only a parity bit and the                       
               corresponding digital data word.  As noted above,                      
               Burghard stores multiple parity bits and so teaches                    
               away.                                                                  

                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007