Ex Parte SYKES - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1999-1045                                                         
          Application No. 08/651,759                                                   


          specification (page 31), read in light of the Figure 35 showing,             
          further reveal the disclosed invention,                                      


                    The forward head 469 can cooperate with, and                       
                    be stabilized by, a desk or other                                  
                    conventional work surface.  More                                   
                    specifically, each forward head 470 is meant                       
                    to contact a bottom surface 476 of the desk                        
                    and be wedged behind, for example, a desk                          
                    drawer 478 or a slide-out keyboard tray such                       
                    as is known in the art.  In this way, the                          
                    platform K provides an additional work                             
                    surface that is rigidly positioned in                              
                    relation to a large work surface.                                  

          At this point, we note that an insert 70 (Fig. 2A) of a suitable             
          thermoplastic material provides “friction properties” so as to               
          retard a sliding movement of the base on the thigh of a user.  In            
          the embodiment depicted in Figure 36, one or more knobs 508                  
          provide a means for “frictionally” retarding longitudinal                    
          movement of a base 498 on a user’s thigh.4                                   


               Independent claim 1 is drawn to a platform for a hand-                  
          controllable data input device used with a microprocessor and an             

               4 The specification does not expressly address frictional               
          properties or characteristics with respect to the mushroom-shaped            
          forward head 468, with or without an optional rubber cap thereon.            
          This matter is raised in a “REMAND TO THE EXAMINER” below,                   
          relative to the claimed contact surface material being “selected             
          to promote friction”.                                                        
                                          5                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007