Ex parte ISHAI et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1999-1598                                                         
          Application 08/668,656                                                       

          Rothfield (e.g., the Databases 2-4 and Source Tables 2-6 in                  
          Fig. 3) are data files.                                                      

               Designating a Sequence of Operations and a Field Range                  
               Claim 1 recites "designating a sequence of user-specified               
          application program data operations on one or more data files;               
          . . . wherein the step of designating includes designating a                 
          field range representing one or more data records contained in               
          a data file that will be used as input to the data operations                
          such that the execution of the data operations will occur on                 
          the designated field range."                                                 
               The Examiner finds that Rothfield teaches designating a                 
          field range 6-2f at column 6, lines 5-68, and Figs. 5-9 (FR2).               
               Appellants argue that Rothfield cannot designate a                      
          sequence of data operations on a designated field range of                   
          data records contained in a data file because the query                      
          language in Rothfield designates keys or columns of tables                   
          (Br6).  It is argued that the present invention designating a                
          field range of records refers to specifying a field name and                 
          field length, wherein the field length can be a byte range                   
          specified irrespective of data record values.  Rothfield's                   
          filter values permit a user to exclude data of an input table                
                                        - 6 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007