Appeal No. 1999-1756 Application No. 08/499,100 claim 1 (as reproduced in the appendix of Paper No. 20) is the spherical outer surface of the collar and the "spherical surfaces" referred to in line 12 of claim 1 are the spherical surfaces of the clamshells. With this understanding of claim 1 in mind, we turn to the prior art relied upon by the examiner in rejecting claim 1. Herrick discloses a vectoring nozzle comprising a collar portion 14 having a spherical external surface, a gimbal ring 22 disposed about the collar and including two opposed gimbal pivots 24, 26 for supporting the gimbal ring relative to the nozzle static structure 28 and upper and lower clamshells 34, 36 supported on the gimbal ring for independent pivotal movement about a common axis 38 oriented both perpendicular to the gimbal axis 30 and transverse to the nozzle center line 40. The nozzle is provided with arcuate seals 72, 74 disposed between the clamshell spherical surfaces 68, 70 and the collar spherical surface 16 for preventing the flow of exhaust gas 6 therebetween. According to Herrick, the seals 72, 74 may be relatively simple in design, such as piston rings or spring seals (col. 3, lines 62-66). 5Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007