Ex parte WONG et al. - Page 10




          Appeal No. 1999-1889                                      Page 10           
          Application No. 08/366,988                                                  


          to be supplied to an ink jet recording head ....”  P. 3,                    
          ll. 3-4.  “[T]he main body of the ink container ...                         
          accomodat[es] a vacuum producing material ....”  P. 7, ll. 40-              
          42.  As shown in Figure 43 of the reference, the “material                  
          2003 is separated into ... parts.”  P. 19, ll. 46-47.  More                 
          specifically, “there are high compression ratio portion A432,"              
          id. at l. 47, and “minimum compression ratio portion A434                   
          ....”  Id. at 47-48.  The Figure also shows that the portions               
          are in surface-to-surface contact with each other.                          


               Because Koitabashi’s vacuum producing material is                      
          separated into a high compression ratio portion and a minimum               
          compression ratio portion and the portions in surface-to-                   
          surface contact with each other, we are persuaded that the                  
          applied prior art discloses the limitations of “first and                   
          second vacuum producing materials respectively having first                 
          and second vacuum producing capacities respectively for                     
          dispensing and storing ink, the first and second materials                  
          being in surface-to-surface contact with each other” and                    
          “first and second vacuum producing materials inside the                     
          cartridge body and respectively having first and second vacuum              







Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007