Ex parte SHIPP - Page 10




          Appeal No. 1999-2039                                      Page 10           
          Application No. 08/531,424                                                  


          chips are not disposed around a central light aperture, and                 
          there is no evidence that Pileski’s arrangement of optical                  
          fibers would have been desirable for the former reference’s                 
          chips, we are not persuaded that teachings from the prior art               
          would have suggested the proposed combination of Kakinuma and               
          Pileski nor the limitations of "b. illumination means mounted               
          at the distal end of said sheath; ... e. the illumination                   
          means comprising a plurality of light emitting diodes arranged              
          in a generally concentric pattern surrounding a light                       
          transmissive central aperture in the center of said pattern,                
          said central aperture having a central axis aligned with and                
          coaxial with a central axis of said objective lens system and               
          with a central axis of said sheath;" “illumination means                    
          mounted at the distal end of a camera sheath, the illumination              
          means comprising a plurality of light emitting diodes arranged              
          in a generally concentric pattern surrounding a light                       
          transmissive central aperture, said central aperture having a               
          central axis coaxially aligned with a central axis of said                  
          camera sheath;” “[a] compact light source for illuminating an               
          object while in a body cavity, said light source comprising                 
          first, second, and third color LED's fixed to a common                      







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007