Appeal No. 1999-2258 Application No. 08/431,720 receives data from either the main memory or the video memory and performs a graphics operation on the data, and a memory controller that controls the memory subsystem so that at one time the datapath circuit receives the data from the main memory and at another time the datapath circuit receives the data from the video memory. Claim 1 is the only independent claim on appeal, and it reads as follows: 1. For use in a computer system having a data processor, a system bus, and a memory subsystem comprising main memory and video memory, a hardware graphics accelerator comprising: a datapath circuit connected to the system bus and to the memory subsystem for receiving data from the memory subsystem, performing a graphics operation upon the data, and returning the data to the memory subsystem; and a memory controller connected to the system bus, to the datapath circuit, and to the memory subsystem for controlling the memory subsystem such that at one time the datapath circuit receives the data from the main memory and at another time the datapath circuit receives the data from the video memory. The reference relied on by the examiner is: Lehman et al. (Lehman) 5,450,542 Sep. 12, 1995 (filed Nov. 30, 1993) Claims 1 through 14 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007