Ex Parte BERRY et al - Page 8



          Appeal No. 1999-2607                                                         
          Application 08/826,618                                                       
          user around, there is no suggestion that the two-dimensional                 
          telephone interface, once opened, lets the user navigate away.               
          Accordingly, we find that Linnett does not disclose "user                    
          interface means for navigating away from said selected virtual               
          object within said three-dimensional workspace, and means for                
          user interactive input to said displayed two-dimensional image,              
          said input means remaining interactive after the user has                    
          navigated away from said selected virtual object," as recited in             
          claim 20 and corresponding limitations in claims 21 and 22.                  
               Lynch does not cure the deficiencies of Linnett, as we will             
          show.  The Examiner's statement of the rejection does not rely on            
          Lynch for anything more than a teaching of a "two-dimensional                
          image of said virtual object," which limitation is not at issue.             
          Nevertheless, some of the Examiner's remarks rely on Lynch and we            
          discuss Lynch and the Examiner's remarks here.                               
               Appellants argue that Lynch relates to navigation in only a             
          two-dimensional display interface having three distinct                      
          two-dimensional levels or layers and, thus, does not relate to               
          navigation on a single level three-dimensional workspace (Br6-7).            
          The Examiner states that the levels are part of one workspace,               
          but, in any case, the room level constitutes a single workspace.             


                                        - 8 -                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007