Ex Parte BROBERG - Page 2


                   Appeal No. 2000-0545                                                                                            
                   Application 08/638,339                                                                                          


                   selected audio/video source to the input receiving circuitry, and a switch controller for                       
                   identifying the audio/video source which corresponds to a received channel request and                          
                   controls the switch to connect the identified source to the input receiving circuitry.                          
                   Specification, page 3, line 25, to page 4, line 1.  Multiple sources having overlapping                         
                   channel assignments are controlled with user input of a channel.  Specification, page 16,                       
                   lines 3-11.                                                                                                     
                          Independent claim 1 is representative and is reproduced as follows:                                      
                   1.     An apparatus for selecting audiovisual signals from two or more sources of such                          
                   signals having overlapping channel number assignments and delivering the selected                               
                   audiovisual signals to an audio/video input, the apparatus comprising, a memory for                             
                   storing a user built channel map comprising a plurality of user channel identifiers that                        
                   have each been assigned by the user to correlate to one of the channel numbers of the two                       
                   or more sources, a switch for selecting one of the sources for connection to the                                
                   audio/video input, and a controller in communication with the memory for controlling the                        
                   switch to connect the audio/video input to the source of the channel number correlated to                       
                   a requested user channel identifier.                                                                            
                          In rejecting Appellant’s claims, the Examiner relies on the following references:                        
                   Klosterman                    5,550,576                    Aug. 27, 1996                                      
                   Beery                         5,045,947                    Sep.    3, 1991                                    
                          Claims 1-29 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as obvious over Klosterman                              
                   and Beery.                                                                                                      
                          Rather than repeat the arguments of Appellant and Examiner, we refer the reader                          
                   to Appellant’s Briefs1 and Examiner’s Answer2 for the respective details thereof.                               





                                                                                                                                  
                   1 Appellant filed an Appeal Brief on March 19, 1999 and a Reply Brief on July 20, 1999.                         
                   2 The Examiner, in response to Appellant’s Brief, mailed an Examiner’s Answer on May 24, 1999.                  

                                                                2                                                                  



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007