Ex Parte WILLMAN et al - Page 12



          Appeal No. 2000-1260                                                            
          Application 08/518,852                                                          

          configuration data being a set of configuration data that was                   
          used when the computer program was previously booted                            
          successfully.                                                                   
               Upon careful review of Garner, we find that Garner’s                       
          invention is motivated by overcoming past problems that occurred                
          when a user moved an “already bootable computer” from one place                 
          to another and the peripherals changed.  See column 1 lines 35-50               
          of Garner.  Specifically, we find that Garner is not directed to                
          the problems of “initial booting” of a computer but rather to the               
          problems of being able to switch between one peripheral and                     
          another “after the system is booted.”  See column 1 lines 58-64.                
          This is done by the accessing of a database that contains                       
          information for the different peripherals that might be used                    
          (i.e. a printer at a home office or a different type of printer                 
          at a work office) and loading the appropriate data to allow                     
          interaction between said “already” booted computer with the                     
          peripheral of choice.  See column 2 lines 12-17 and claim 1 of                  
          Garner.  To further support the finding above, we note that                     
          Garner specifically discloses a system that provides for the                    
          dynamic configuration system of a portable computer that                        
          contains,                                                                       

                                            12                                            




Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007