Ex Parte BLANTS et al - Page 2




                Appeal No. 2000-2238                                                                                 Page 2                    
                Application No. 08/826,922                                                                                                     


                         According to the appellants, when a user created a short message, heretofore,                                         
                he formed the message one character at a time.  (Id.)   Because digital mobile phones                                          
                usually do not contain letter keys, they explain, the user entered letters by pressing                                         
                numbers, special characters, and function keys in a certain order.  (Id.)  Because the                                         
                selection of a letter required several keystrokes, add the appellants, forming a textual                                       
                message by such means was slow.  (Id.)                                                                                         


                         In contrast, the appellants’ digital mobile phone uses menus to form a message.                                       
                More specifically, a user selects parts of the message based on questions or options                                           
                presented by menus of the phone.  (Id.)  The phone compiles responses from the user                                            
                into a short message for transmission.  (Id. at 2.)                                                                            


                         A further understanding of the invention can be achieved by reading the following                                     
                claim:                                                                                                                         
                                 7. A method for creating a short message on an electrical                                                     
                         communication device, which short message is a string of characters                                                   
                         complying with a predetermined structure, characterized in that the                                                   
                         communication device presents to the user data input options according                                                
                         to said structure and, in response to data entered by the user, said                                                  
                         communication device compiles said short message in accordance with                                                   
                         said structure, wherein the message is in human readable form.                                                        


                         Claims 1-4, 6-9, and 11-14 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 102(e) as                                                 
                anticipated by U.S. Patent No. 5,887,249 (“Schmid”).                                                                           







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007