Ex Parte SCHADE et al - Page 3


                Appeal No. 2001-1241                                                     Page 3                  
                Application No. 09/101,234                                                                       

                emulsions.  See id., page 2.  “The pressed agglomerates produced according to                    
                the prior art do not disintegrate completely in the oil phase . . ., so that the                 
                subsequent addition of water and/or a base results in the formation of mixtures                  
                containing large, lumpy pieces of gel.”  Id.                                                     
                       The specification discloses “low-dust, free-flowing granular materials                    
                comprising pulverulent polymer which can be incorporated into oil phases without                 
                the disadvantages described,” making them suitable for use in cosmetics and                      
                pharmaceuticals.  Id.  “[T]his object is achieved by addition of at least one oil-               
                soluble component to the pulverulent polymer before or during press                              
                agglomeration to give a granular material which can be dispersed very well in oil                
                and additionally can be handled without complicated safety measures.”  Id.                       
                                                   Discussion                                                    
                       As we interpret it, claim 1 is directed to a granular material made by                    
                pressing a mixture of an oil-soluble component and at least one carboxyl-                        
                containing polymer;1 the polymer in the claimed material is made by free-radical-                
                initiated copolymerization of a monomer mixture comprising at least three                        
                components:  (a) a monoethylenically unsaturated mono- or dicarboxylic acid (50                  
                to 99.93% by weight of the mixture), (b) a compound having at least two                          
                ethylenically unsaturated, nonconjugated double bonds as a cross-linker (0.05 to                 
                5% by weight of the mixture), and (c) an alkyl (meth)acrylate (0.02 to 10% by                    

                                                                                                                 
                1 The language of claim 1 is somewhat ambiguous.  For example, the claim refers to both a        
                “carboxyl-containing polymer as main component” and a “polymer component;” we interpret both     
                of these phrases to refer to the copolymer comprising monomers (a) through (d).  The claim also  
                states that “use if made of a polymer component;” we interpret this phrase to mean simply that   
                the claimed granular material comprises the recited polymer component.                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007