Ex Parte BERNARD - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2001-1473                                                        
          Application 08/946,736                                                      

          the motor, either Borazon or diamond cutting grit electroplated             
          on the cutting surfaces of the wheels 20, 22, and a drill chuck             
          24 having peripheral cam surfaces 48 and 50.                                
               The appellant does not dispute the examiner’s assessment               
          (see page 5 in the revised answer) that Christian responds to all           
          of the limitations in claim 29 except for those requiring a                 
          grinding wheel which comprises a hollow cylindrical metal ring              
          having diamond particles plated to its outer surface and a hub              
          around which the cylindrical ring is fitted, wherein the hub                
          includes means for coupling to a motor shaft.  To cure these                
          deficiencies in Christian, the examiner turns to Wiand.                     
               Wiand discloses several embodiments of a grinding wheel                
          generally composed of a core element rigidly secured to a drive             
          shaft via a set screw and typically made of brass, and a drop-on            
          cylindrical grinding bit slidably engageable with, and readily              
          removable from, a cylindrical portion of the core element and               
          made of a metal such as brass or steel with a diamond abrasive              
          grit electroplated thereon.  According to Wiand (see column 1,              
          lines 50 through 60; column 2, lines 53 through 57; and column 6,           
          lines 4 through 12), the two-part nature of the assembly permits            
          worn grinding surfaces to be replaced in an expeditious and cost            
          effective manner.                                                           

                                          5                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007