Ex Parte WILLIS et al - Page 4




              Appeal No. 2001-1626                                                                                      
              Application No. 09/007,622                                                                                

              video files.  If a requested video in its entirety is present in local cache 15, VDMS 12                  
              allows real time playback of the video file to the user station over LAN 16.  If only an                  
              initial portion (or “preface”) of a video file is present in cache 15, then VDMS 12 allows                
              playback of the preface of the video file to the user over LAN 16 while the remainder of                  
              the video file is transferred to local cache 15, effecting a “speed match” playback.                      
              Greenwood further describes, in column 5, lines 10 through 50, determining whether                        
              the bandwidth available for WAN 13 (and the storage capacity of the local cache) is                       
              sufficient to transmit a video file from library 11 to a local cache in sufficient time to                
              meet a video playback schedule requested by a user.                                                       
                     Miller describes (Fig. 1) a network resource scheduler 10 that communicates with                   
              content sources 12, 14 over network 24 and schedules data transmission from the                           
              content sources to replicated servers 16, 18, 20.  Data delivered to the replicated                       
              servers can be retransmitted to subscribers (221, 222, 223, ..., 22N) over further networks               
              (26, 28).  Network resource scheduler 10 determines whether data transmission from                        
              content sources to particular replicated servers can be completed by a delivery time                      
              requested by the content sources.  Col. 4, ll. 34-58.                                                     
                     Although the rejection as set forth in the Answer points to various elements in the                
              references which are deemed to correspond to features in the instant claims, we find                      
              ourselves, after careful consideration of the examiner’s position and extensive review of                 
              the references, substantially in agreement with appellants’ position set forth at pages 6                 
              and 7 of the Reply Brief.  In our view, Greenwood is directed to providing information                    
                                                          -4-                                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007