Ex Parte BERNHARDT - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2002-0095                                                        
          Application No. 09/378,051                                                  


               Claim 7 is drawn to a bowling ball insert comprising, inter            
          alia, a tubular body defining first and second finger openings at           
          opposite terminal ends, a first finger gripping member adjacent             
          the first finger opening, a second finger gripping member                   
          adjacent the first finger opening and directly opposing and being           
          different than the first finger gripping member, a third finger             
          gripping member adjacent the second finger opening, a fourth                
          finger gripping member adjacent the second finger opening and               
          directly opposing and being different than the first (sic, third)           
          finger gripping member.4                                                    


               Claim 13 recites a bowling ball assembly, comprising, inter            
          alia, a bowling ball, a resilient insert defining first and                 
          second finger openings at opposite terminal ends of said body               
          (sic, insert),5 a first finger gripping member adjacent the first           


               4 The language in the penultimate paragraph of claim 7 is              
          informal, when read in light of the specification (page 2, lines            
          1 through 10), in referencing said “third” finger gripping member           
          (rather than said --fourth-- finger gripping member) directly               
          opposing said third gripping member, and in setting forth said              
          “first” finger gripping member rather than said --third-- finger            
          gripping member.                                                            
               5 In lines 5 through 8 of claim 13, the phrases “said outer            
          wall surface” and “said body” (two occurrences) are informal in             
          that they have no explicit antecedent basis in the claim.                   
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007