Ex Parte LIPRIE - Page 12




          Appeal No. 2002-0933                                                        
          Application No. 09/325,944                                                  


          answer.  Appellant urges that Rague (col. 6, lines 56-59) merely            
          indicates that elements (78) and (80) are connected together to             
          assure a continuous electrical supply to the unit, and thus those           
          elements in the Rague patent do not constitute a "presence                  
          sensing mechanism" which provides an indication of connection               
          upon substantially complete mating of the first and second mating           
          surfaces, as required in independent claim 9 and its dependent              
          claims.  In appellant's view, Rague merely emphasizes a                     
          continuous supply of electrical power without qualification as to           
          whether the connector is substantially completely mated.                    


          We agree with appellant that elements (78) and (80) of Rague                
          appear to be designed to provide a supply of electrical power to            
          the unit without regard to whether the first and second mating              
          surfaces of the connectors (34, 36) or (37, 41) are substantially           
          completely mated or not.  Claim 9 specifies that "upon                      
          substantially complete mating of the first and second mating                
          surfaces, the presence sensing mechanism provides an indication             














Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007