EDWARDS et al. V. LEVEEN - Page 31






          Interference No. 104,290                                                           




          his testimony. LR128, line 24. We are in full agreement that                       

          the experiments were of an exploratory nature and were not                         

          intended or designed to be a reduction to practice of the subject                  

          matter of the interference.                                                        

                     In summary, it is our determination that the series of                  

          experiments from June through October 1993 were not a reduction                    

          to practice of the subject matter of the count.                                    



          Abandonment, Suppression or Concealment                                            

                     Edwards raises the issue of abandonment, suppression,                   

          or concealment on the part of LeVeen. As noted above, we have                      

          determined that LeVeen failed to reduce the invention to practice                  

          by successful testing of the subject matter of the count in the                    

          June through October time frame. Accordingly, we do not reach                      

          the issue of the alleged abandonment, suppression, or conceal                      

          ment. "[W]ithout an actual reduction to practice there is no                       

          invention in existence which can be abandoned, suppressed, or                      

          concealed." Peeler v. Miller, 535 F.2d 647, 651, 190 USPQ 117,                     

          120 (CCPA 1976).                                                                   








                                             31                                              








Page:  Previous  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007