Ex Parte CHOW et al - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2001-0513                                                        
          Application No. 09/096,550                                                  


               Each of the independent claims in one form or another                  
          recites a retrieval of the components from the non-local memory             
          at a rate independent of a rate in which the components were                
          written into the non-local memory.  The examiner asserts (Answer,           
          pages 4-5) that Artieri teaches in column 4, lines 14-20 and                
          column 7, lines 17-21 that "the packet processing module                    
          retrieves the components from the non-local memory at a rate                
          independent of a rate in which the components were written into             
          the non-local memory."  The cited portions of Artieri are as                
          follows:                                                                    
                    According to an embodiment of the invention, the                  
               system includes a variable length decoder (VLD) forming                
               the master processing element; a run-level decoder                     
               (RLD) forming a first element of the pipeline circuit                  
               and receiving through the parameter bus the packets                    
               processed by the VLD . . .                                             
          and                                                                         
                    A picture header includes, as mentioned above, a                  
               picture type parameter and information on the use of                   
               the movement compensation vectors.  These parameters                   
               are used by the VLD circuit itself to decode the                       
               vectors and data of the macro-blocks.                                  
               We find nothing in either of the two passages that would               
          suggest retrieving components from the non-local memory at a rate           
          independent of a rate in which the components were written into             
          the non-local memory, as claimed.  The examiner further explains            


                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007