Ex Parte GULICK - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2001-0594                                                        
          Application No. 08/929,153                                                  

          that the bus coupling the two integrated circuits have signal               
          lines including a bus clock, a data in signal line and a data out           
          signal line and that the signal lines, including the bus clock,             
          be inactive when the bus is placed in a reduced power consumption           
          state.  Moreover, the existence of the wake-up event recited in             
          the preamble of the claim must be signaled “by changing at least            
          one signal line of the bus from a first voltage level to a second           
          voltage level while the bus clock is inactive, in response to the           
          wake-up event detected by the second integrated circuit.”                   
               While the examiner points to Walsh, at column 29, lines 49-            
          56, and column 27, line 66 to column 28, line 2, for changing a             
          signal line of the bus from a first voltage to a second voltage             
          in response to a wake-up event recognized by the second                     
          integrated circuit, our review of these portions of Walsh does              
          not comport with the examiner’s position.                                   
               These portions of Walsh relate to the six states of a state            
          machine shown in Figure 23.  We find nothing therein, and the               
          examiner has not convincingly pointed to anything therein, that             
          relates to the bus 104 having a bus clock, and data in and data             
          out signal lines wherein the signal lines and the clock are                 
          inactive when the bus is placed in a reduced power consumption              
          state and wherein the existence of a wake-up event is signaled              
                                         -5–                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007