Ex Parte GHOSAL et al - Page 7




          Appeal No. 2001-0742                                                        
          Application 09/128,912                                                      



                    Appellants urge that despite the fact that the                    
          polymeric compositions of the references may be similar to                  
          appellants’ composition, the claimed films are not the same as              
          those of the cited references, because “the composition of a                
          latex polymer clearly does not solely dictate final physical end            
          properties of crosslinked films made therefrom.”  Appeal Brief,             
          page 4.  In particular, appellants note that the extent of latex            
          film crosslinking is due to a number of factors such as gel                 
          content, swell area, etc. which are dependent upon processing               
          temperature, extent of conversion, rate of reaction, polymer                
          concentration, catalyst concentration, etc.  Id.  Appellants                
          further note that film performance properties are influenced                
          during the inherent stage of polymer formation as well as during            
          post polymerization crosslinking, which is influenced by factors            
          such as cure additives.  Id.  In support of their position,                 
          appellants reference three separate articles which were submitted           
          with appellants’ amendment received December 9, 1999, Paper No.             
          9.  Appellants rely on these articles as proof that the                     
          properties of latex polymers are determined by variables other              
          than composition alone.                                                     



                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007