Ex Parte KIM - Page 11



          Appeal No. 2002-1006                                                        
          Application 09/132,351                                                      

          being a separately defined field.  In particular, Sanders teaches           

          in column 10, lines 17 through 40, that figure 6 illustrates a              
          flow diagram of the steps executed by a communication device and            
          a dispatch short message service communication.  The project flow           
          begins (601) when the communication device transmits (603) an SMS           
          call request together with a short message to a dispatch                    
          controller located logically, and preferably physically, external           
          to the existing network.  The SMS call request includes an ID of            
          the communication device and an address of the dispatch                     
          controller.  As described above, the dispatch controller utilizes           
          the communication device ID or the target address of the dispatch           
          controller contained in the SMS call request to determine the               
          communication network talk group and the associated talk group              
          members.  Thus, either the ID of the communication device or the            
          address of the dispatch controller reads on Appellant’s claimed             
          group identifier.  The communication device ID or a target                  
          address is associated with a plurality of subscriber numbers,               
          associated talk group members.  This is further buttressed by               
          Sanders’ teaching in column 10, lines 42 through 52, which states           
          that cellular telephone users can engage in dispatch or group               
          calls, or send short messages to a group of target users, with a            
                                          11                                          




Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007