Ex Parte DE SORGO - Page 6




              Appeal No. 2003-0672                                                                  Page 6                 
              Application No. 09/151,886                                                                                   


                     IBM TDB No. NA9001182 teaches using an aluminum nitride ceramic with a                                
              thickness of 60 mils cut to the size of the chip as a heat material that is adhesively                       
              bonded to the back of a silicon chip mounted on a substrate.  IBM TDB No. NA9001182                          
              also teaches that current alumina cermamic cannot complete heat removal from the                             
              chips and that the perferred material for the heat sink is aluminum nitride which offers                     
              thermal conductivity close to aluminum metal and a matched thermal expansion                                 
              coefficient with the chip.  IBM TDB No. NA9001182 does not teach or suggest using a                          
              generally planar thermal dissipation member formed of a thermally conductive,                                
              electrically-nonconductive ceramic aluminum oxide material having a thickness of less                        
              than about 100 mils (2.5 mm) which extends generally coterminously with or within the                        
              margins of the second heat transfer surface of the source.                                                   


                     Kurokawa discloses a high density, high heat dissipating, high reliable package                       
              structure for semiconductor devices.  Kurokawa teaches (column 3, lines 20-28) that:                         
                            The heat sink can be formed of a single substance material or a                                
                     composite material, such as aluminum nitride, aluminum carbide, alumina, boron                        
                     nitride, beryllium oxide, silicon, diamond, copper, tungsten, aluminum, since                         
                     these materials have a good heat conductivity and therefore are preferable from                       
                     the total viewpoint of a heat dissipation property and a connection reliability.                      
                     However, the heat sink is in no way limited to the materials mentioned above.                         
              As shown in the drawings, the heat sink is larger than chip.  Kurokawa does not teach                        
              or suggest using a generally planar thermal dissipation member formed of a thermally                         
              conductive, electrically-nonconductive ceramic aluminum oxide material having a                              







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007