CHEN et al. v BOUCHARD et al. - Page 53



          Interference No. 103,675                                                      

    et al. could not have relied on the APJ's "representations" in this                 
    proceeding to "diligently prepare its evidence" in February 2000, when              
    that evidence had already been taken and filed in another proceeding                
    in November 1999. Accordingly, we find that the motions to reopen were              
    properly dismissed or, in the alternative, properly denied.                         
              Finally, Bouchard et al. urge that the APJ should have                    
    granted its motion to strike certain evidence filed by Chen et al.                  
    with their reply to Bouchard et al.'s opposition to Chen et al.'s                   
    preliminary motions for benefit. We disagree. As correctly noted by                 
    the APJ, because she deferred the motions for benefit to final hearing              
    and gave the parties a testimony period for taking evidence on the                  
    issues raised by the motions for benefit, the motion to strike the                  
    evidence was rendered moot.                                                         
                             THE MOTIONS TO SUPPRESS                                    
              Both parties have filed motions to suppress certain evidence              
    proffered by their respective opponent in this interference. Chen et                
    al. seek in two, separate motions, to exclude (suppress) various parts              
    of Bouchard et al.'s record and certain of Bouchard et al.'s exhibits.              
    Bouchard et al. seek to exclude (suppress) all laboratory notebooks of              
    Ms. Jianmei Wei from the evidence on which Chen et al. may rely and                 
    all of Dr. Chen's testimony relating to the laboratory notebooks of                 
    Ms. Jianmei Wei.                                                                    
                                        53                                              


Page:  Previous  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007