HENKEL CORP. v PROCTOR & GAMBLE - Page 4




                  Interference No. 105,174                                                                               Paper 86                              
                  Henkel v. P&G                                                                                          Page 4                                
                            solution or melt region occupying no greater than 40% by volume of the tablet                                                      
                            (id., pp. 26-37).                                                                                                                  
                  7.        As a result of the Decision and the “ORDER - MISCELLANEOUS - Bd. R.                                                                
                            104(a)” (“Order,” Paper 77), new claims 41 and 44 were added to Henkel                                                             
                            applications ‘434 and ‘578, respectively, and the remaining patentable claims of                                                   
                            the parties are:                                                                                                                   
                            Henkel ‘434 application                                 41                                                                         
                            Henkel ‘578 application                                 44                                                                         
                            P&G ‘564 patent                                         1-14                                                                       
                  8.        Henkel ‘434 application claim 41 reads:                                                                                            
                                     A detergent tablet comprising a compressed region and a solidified                                                        
                            solution or melt region wherein:                                                                                                   
                                     a)  the compressed region comprises a recess and the dissolution                                                          
                            rate of the compressed region is greater than the dissolution rate of the                                                          
                            solidified solution or melt region;                                                                                                
                                     b)  the solution or melt region is delivered onto the recess and the                                                      
                            solidified solution or melt region is at least partially retained within the                                                       
                            recess;                                                                                                                            
                                     c)  the solidified solution or melt region is affixed to the compressed                                                   
                            region by hardening; and                                                                                                           
                                     d)  the solidified solution or melt region comprises no more than                                                         
                            40% of the surface of the detergent tablet.                                                                                        
                  9.        Henkel ‘578 application claim 44 reads:                                                                                            
                                     A detergent tablet comprising (a) a compressed region containing                                                          
                            an active detergent ingredient, and (b) a solidified melt or solution region                                                       
                            comprising an active detergent ingredient, wherein the tablet as a whole                                                           
                            dissolves in less than 40 minutes in a dishwashing machine, wherein the                                                            
                            dissolution rate of the compressed region is greater than the dissolution                                                          
                            rate of the solidified melt or solution region, wherein the solidified melt or                                                     
                            solution region is solidified in a recess formed in the compressed portion,                                                        
                            and wherein the solidified melt or solution region comprises no more than                                                          
                            40% by volume of the detergent tablet.                                                                                             







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007