Ex Parte TAKAGI et al - Page 9




          Appeal No. 2002-1940                                                        
          Application 08/932,649                                                      


          ability to fulfill the higher elevation teachings of Aviv would             
          have been well appreciated by the artisan.  Kuo's digital                   
          elevation information is stored in a database for later use                 
          (Figures 1, 9A, 9B).                                                        
               Moreover, we observe that the topographic elevation                    
          capabilities in Kuo relate to features or objects that are                  
          derived from the particular viewing perspective.  Kuo discusses             
          in detail various point features or various image features                  
          throughout the reference, such as at column 6, lines 7-10; column           
          15, line 66 through column 16, line 5, and the need to cure the             
          deficiency of the prior art discussed at column 2, lines 37-46              
          of identification of image features.  These obviously would have            
          corresponded to the objects or people in the context of the                 
          Aviv's teachings when considered together with this reference.              
               Taken in this light, it is apparent to us that the artisan             
          would have found it obvious to have combined the teachings of Kuo           
          into those of Aviv to further enhance the ability of Aviv's                 
          system to provide more valid and accurate elevated perspective              
          information for his surveillance system.  Indeed, one of the                
          major aims of Kuo is to provide improved accuracy of digital                
          elevation information as expressed in Kuo's Summary of the                  


                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007