Ex Parte QUAN et al - Page 10

                 Appeal No.  2003-1679                                                       Page 10                  
                 Application No.  08/993,010                                                                          
                        Having determined that the examiner has not established a prima facie                         
                 case of obviousness, we find it unnecessary to discuss the del Giudice                               
                 Declaration, relied on by appellants (Brief, pages 20-23) to rebut any such prima                    
                 facie case.                                                                                          



                                                    REVERSED                                                          


                                                                        )                                             
                                      Sherman D. Winters                )                                             
                                      Administrative Patent Judge       )                                             
                                                                        )                                             
                                                                        )                                             
                                                                        ) BOARD OF PATENT                             
                                      Toni R. Scheiner                 )                                             
                                      Administrative Patent Judge       )   APPEALS AND                               
                                                                        )                                             
                                                                        ) INTERFERENCES                               
                                                                        )                                             
                                      Donald E. Adams                   )                                             
                                      Administrative Patent Judge       )                                             





















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November  3, 2007