Appeal No. 2004-0316
Application 09/136,619
claims on appeal. Appellant groups all independent claims 1, 10,
16, and 22 together with independent claim 1 as representative
thereof. Appellant also presents dependent claims 25-28 as
falling together in a separate grouping. Note the top of page 4
of the brief.
At page 4 of the brief, appellant urges that Wen fails to
disclose markings which specify images that correspond to the
print images, where the markings are displayed in printing
together with the print images on the CD. The ensuing discussion
recognizes that column 1, lines 48-61 of Wen teaches the
thumbnail images recited in the body of independent claim 1 on
appeal which is stated there to form the so-called index print of
the preamble of that claim. Page 5 of the brief urges that the
only text contemplated by Wen regards the descriptive contents of
the CD and that there is no teaching or suggestion of specific
information that would map out the location of thumbnail images
on a CD. Finally, appellant recognizes in the paragraph bridging
pages 5 and 6 of the brief that Wen mentions the desire to print
thumbnail images "as" an index on a CD surface. This is correct
in that column 1, lines 50 and 51 indicate that "thumbnail images
can be printed on the label as an index of the images stored in
3
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007