Ex Parte Wolfe - Page 17




          Appeal No. 2004-1586                                                         
          Application No. 10/132,863                                                   


                                     OTHER ISSUES                                      
               We note that many commercial or business entities, such as              
          PETCO PALS, Verizon, Giant, Blockbuster, CVS/Pharmacy, and GNC,              
          employ small advertising and/or reward plastics to be used with a            
          key chain.  Some of these advertising and/or reward plastics,                
          e.g., CVS/Pharmacy and Verizon plastic cards having indicia in               
          distinct locations, have a plurality of sub-sections and a                   
          punched hole for inserting a key chain therethrough.  Other                  
          advertising and/or reward plastics, such as Blockbuster and                  
          CVS/Pharmacy cards having punched holes for key chains, employ               
          bar codes for the purpose of giving credits to customers by a                
          business entity for each business transaction or purchase                    
          occurred or for the purpose of giving discounts to customers by a            
          business entity for a given business transaction or purchase.                
          These cards are designed to be used with a key chain, thus at                
          least suggesting the subject matter of claim 1.  Moreover, as is             
          also apparent from Edge and Sports Pub discussed above, their                
          cards, which are capable of being punched out to reflect each                
          business transaction, provide the same function as the                       
          conventional key chain cards having bar codes discussed above.               
               Thus, in the event of further prosecution, the examiner is              
          advised to obtain the dates on which these cards were available              

                                          17                                           





Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007