Ex Parte Hoffman et al - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2004-2234                                                        
          Application No. 09/881,361                                                  

                                     DISCUSSION                                       
               Shimazaki, the examiner’s primary reference, discloses a               
          system for adjusting the swing balance of a golf club.  Of                  
          particular interest is the embodiment illustrated in Figures 1              
          and 2:                                                                      
               [a]s in a first embodiment as shown in Fig. 1,                         
               hosel part 2 is provided on head body 1, and shaft 4 is                
               inserted in inserting hole 3 of hosel part 2.  Lower                   
               hole 10 extended to the sole 1A side of head body 1 is                 
               formed apparently on an extended line of inserting hole                
               3 of hosel part 2.  Balance adjusting weight 11 is then                
               provided inside lower hole 10.  In the embodiment,                     
               inserting hole 3 and lower hole 10 are continuously                    
               provided, and the diameter of lower hole 10 is made                    
               slightly smaller than that of inserting hole 3.  The                   
               diameters of inserting hole 3 and lower hole 10 can                    
               also be equivalent without any problem.  Fig. 2                        
               illustrates weight 11 and shaft 4 attached to each                     
               other.  Reference number 12 refers to a socket.  An                    
               adhesive is poured in inserting hole 3 and lower hole                  
               10 in advance as similar to as in prior art golf clubs.                
               Both weight 11 and the tip of shaft 4 are adhered in                   
               the respective holes with the adhesive.  The following                 
               four types of weights at the following weights are                     
               prepared: a plastic weight at 0.5 g; an aluminum alloy                 
               weight at 1.0 g; a stainless [steel] weight at 2.0 g;                  
               and a lead weight at 3.0 g.  These weights are formed                  
               as cylinders of an equivalent volume and shape and                     
               selected according to the swing balance to be adjusted                 
               [translation, page 3, paragraph 0007].                                 
               With regard to the balance adjusting weights, Shimazaki                
          additionally teaches that                                                   
               [w]eights 11 can be formed using an equivalent                         
               material alone or various materials by a combination                   
               when they are fixed.  The following materials at the                   
               following specific gravities are also utilized other                   
                                          4                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007