Barton et al or Fischhoff et al v. Adang et al. - Page 53




          Interference 103,781                                                        

          actual reduction to practice of the invention defined by Count 2            
          was not prior to the filing date of the earliest application                
          upon which Adang is entitled to rely for benefit (i.e., USSN                
          07/242,482, filed September 9, 1988)” (Paper No. 223, p. 43).               
          However, Adang maintains that it first conceived of the invention           
          of Count 2 on November 6, 1985, and exercised reasonable                    
          diligence during the period beginning prior to November 6, 1985,            
          until constructive reduction to practice of the invention of                
          Count 2 on September 9, 1988 (Paper No. 223, p. 43).                        
               According to Senior Party Adang’s Brief At Final Hearing,              
          Fischhoff’s Supplemental Preliminary Statement indicates that               
          Fischhoff first conceived of the invention of Count 2 on                    
          October 30, 1986 (Paper No. 223, p. 43).  However, “Fischhoff’s             
          first actual reduction to practice of the invention defined by              
          Count 2 was on December 29, 1987" (Paper No. 223, p. 43).                   
               Having considered all the evidence of record, the evidence             
          clearly and convincingly shows that Fischhoff actually reduced              
          the invention of Count 2 to practice no later than August 10,               
          1988, and that Fischhoff conceived of the invention of Count 2              
          no later than December 12, 1986.  On the other hand, the                    
          preponderance of the evidence of record indicates that Adang not            
          only did not exercise reasonable diligence during the critical              
          period just prior to Fischhoff’s latest date of conception of the           

                                        -53-                                          





Page:  Previous  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  59  60  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007