STICE et al v. CAMPBELL et al - Page 12



          Interference 104,746                                    Paper 123           
          Stice v. Campbell                                                           
          any entries in Cibelli's notebooks vis-à-vis any count; nor are             
          any of the data in the notebook explained as to their origin,               
          meaning, or reliability.                                                    
          Diligence                                                                   
               45. Campbell has been accorded the benefit for priority in             
          this interference of its UK application, filed on 31 August 1995.           
          (Paper 81 at 3)                                                             
               46. Stice cites a second entry from Dr. Stice's notebook as            
          evidence of the beginnings of a "concerted effort to reduce this            
          invention to practice:  "Try [sic: Tried] to use the                        
          electroporation to introduce $-geo into fibroblast cells bovine             
          (Jose's). The idea is to use these transgenic cells in NT to                
          produce fetuses and offspring? machine?").  (Paper 92 at 10,                
          square bracketed remarks added by Stice omitted.)                           
               47. Stice provides a table that begins at page 10 of its               
          priority brief and runs to the top of page 21, in which dates are           
          paired against brief descriptions of activity, which are said to            
          be summaries of notebook pages from Dr. Jose Cibelli's laboratory           
          notebook.                                                                   
               48. Stice, in its principal brief, has not directed our                
          attention to any testimony explaining the meaning or significance           
          of any entries in the table.                                                

                                        -12-                                          




Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007