Ex Parte CHOUDARY et al - Page 5


                   Appeal No. 2004-2134                                                                Page 5                      
                   Application No. 09/425,075                                                                                      

                          Cregg is cited for teaching the use of the AOX1 for the expression of                                    
                   foreign proteins in Pichia pastoris.  See id.                                                                   
                          Robinson is cited for teaching “methods of expression of antibodies in                                   
                   yeast with expression plasmids comprising the light chain and heavy chains each                                 
                   attached to a yeast promoter and terminator and are placed on the same                                          
                   plasmid.”  Id.  Robinson is also cited for teaching that “yeast is a preferred host                             
                   because yeast provides substantial advantages for the production of                                             
                   immunoglobulin light and heavy chains because yeast carry out post-translational                                
                   peptide modifications including glycosylation,” and for teaching that “a number of                              
                   recombinant DNA strategies exist which utilize strong promoter sequences and                                    
                   high copy number plasmids which can be used for overt production of the                                         
                   proteins in yeast.”  Id.                                                                                        
                          The Invitrogen catalog is cited for teaching high copy number vectors for                                
                   expression of proteins in P. pastoris, wherein the vectors include the inducible                                
                   AOX1 promoter, a poly cloning site sequence, the alpha-factor signal sequence.                                  
                   See id. at 4-5.                                                                                                 
                          The Answer asserts that:                                                                                 
                                  One of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to                                    
                          produce the claimed method and vectors and host cell because                                             
                          Horwitz [ ] teach[es] recombinant production of proteins,                                                
                          specifically, an antibody in S. cerevisiae in general with selection,                                    
                          screening, and purification and testing antigen binding.  In addition,                                   
                          one of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to                                            
                          produce the claimed method and vectors and host cell in P.                                               
                          pastoris because Cregg [ ] teach[es] production of heterologous                                          
                          proteins in P. pastoris overcomes the problems associated with                                           
                          producing commercially useful levels of proteins in S. cerevisiae                                        
                          (see page 33, introduction) and the P. pastoris is ideally suited for                                    





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007