Appeal No. 2005-0293 Application No. 09/727,139 the surface of etch stop layer 16 to form a first reaction product edge portion 32 and a second reaction product edge 34 and leave a residual layer 36 (column 4, lines 40-43; Fig. 6); preferentially removing cap layer 26 (and preferably also etch stop layer 16) (column 5, lines 4-25; Fig. 7); selectively etching (by either a selective isotropic wet etching process or a downstream isotropic plasma etching process) first and second reaction product edge portions 32 and 34 (column 5, lines 27-45; Fig. 8); and removing portions of etch stop layer 16 (by RIE) exposed by residual layer 36 to form a hard mask 22 with reduced lateral dimension (D2) (column 5, lines 46-67; Fig. 9). Nakajima, the other relied upon prior art reference common to all four rejections, discloses a method for manufacturing a semiconductor device as follows (column 2, line 45 to column 3, line 26): A method for manufacturing a semiconductor device according to a second aspect of this invention comprises the steps of forming a groove portion whose side surface is formed of a first insulating film and whose bottom surface is formed of a silicon film and a third insulating film lying around the first insulating film on a main surface of a semiconductor substrate on which a gate insulating film is formed; forming a first metal film on the silicon film of the bottom portion of the groove portion; reacting the silicon film and the first metal film by a heat 5Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007