Appeal No. 2005-1108 Application No. 10/442,900 (specification, page 1). Representative claim 1 reads as follows:1 1. A wafer carrier for retaining at least one semiconductor wafer in a processing apparatus during a processing operation which removes wafer material by at least one of abrading and chemical reaction, said processing apparatus adapted for removing wafer material from a front side and a back side of each wafer simultaneously, the carrier comprising: a plate including wafer contaminating material and having an opening and a thickness; and an insert having a thickness and being disposed in the opening of the plate for receiving at least one wafer and engaging a peripheral edge of the wafer to hold the wafer as the carrier rotates, the thickness of the insert being at least about 20 microns greater than the thickness of the plate to inhibit removal of the contaminating material from the plate during processing and thereby inhibit contamination of the wafer. THE PRIOR ART The references relied on by the examiner to support the final rejection are: Desai et al. 5,422,316 Jun. 06, 1995 (Desai) Zhang et al. 6,454,635 Sep. 24, 2002 (Zhang) 1 1 In the event of further prosecution, steps should be taken to correct the lack of proper antecedent basis in claim 5 for the reference to “the surface area of exposed metal” and the inconsistency between the preambles of dependent claims 21 through 25 and the subject matter recited in parent claim 20. 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007