Ex Parte Faber - Page 3




             Appeal No. 2005-1201                                                               3              
             Application No. 09/883,357                                                                        


             path of the microscope.  The examiner acknowledges (answer, page 3) that Fehr does not            
             disclose that “the microscope has an illumination system [that] comprises a light                 
             transmitted system and a fluorescent system.” Turning to Koyama, the examiner states              
             (answer, pages 3 and 4) that “in the embodiment described in column 14 and shown in               
             figure 12, Koyama et al disclose a microscope having an illumination system [that]                
             comprises 1) a light transmitting illumination (63) for providing a bright illuminating pattern   
             to an object, and a fluorescent illumination system (56) for providing excited light to           
             activate fluorescent illumination in the object, and 2) a mechanism (8) supporting different      
             objective lens systems in which a particular objective lens system is selectably inserted         
             into the viewing path of the microscope.”  These findings by the examiner have not been           
             challenged by the appellant.                                                                      
                   The examiner is of the opinion (answer, page 4) that “it would have been obvious to         
             one skilled in the art at the time the invention was made to modify the microscope having         
             an objective lens changer provided by Fehr et al by using an illumination system having           
             both a light transmitted illumination system and a fluorescent illumination system, and a         
             motorized mechanism as suggested by Koyama et al for the purpose of automation [of] the           
             switching of the different objective lens systems in either a bright illumination or a            
             fluorescent illumination.”                                                                        











Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007