Ex Parte Ladwig - Page 4




             Appeal No. 2005-1243                                                                              
             Application No. 10/017,739                                                                        

             principal brief on appeal that McCreery does not gather data, all the while                       
             recognizing at the top of page 2 of the reply brief that McCreery does                            
             gather data to the extent recited in representative claim 1 on appeal.                            
                   It is noted that the claimed “a presence” is not defined to be any                          
             type of structural or software element in the claims on appeal and may be                         
             physically located anywhere on the broadly defined computer network of                            
             this claim.  It appears then that even in McCreery and the claimed the                            
             presence, any gathering function may take place at any point on the                               
             Internet, on any local area network associated with the Internet, and even                        
             internal to the Internet analyzer itself such as its network interface 240 in                     
             Figure 2 and element 316 in Figure 3 as well as the remote access                                 
             interface 310 in Figure 3.  The various nodes or remote computers                                 
             associated with them in McCreery process, send, and otherwise gather                              
             data which are intercepted or captured (answer page 10) in McCreery’s                             
             analyzer.  The assertion at page 7 of the principal brief on appeal that                          
             claim 1 requires the heterogeneous data not be intercepted between nodes                          
             of computers as in McCreery is misplaced since such a feature is not                              
             recited in claim 1 on appeal.                                                                     
                                                      -4-                                                      





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007