Ex Parte KRAUS - Page 11



             Appeal No. 2005-0841                                                                                 
             Application No. 08/230,083                                                                           

                          47. U.S. Patent 5,105,731 issued April 21, 1992, based                                  
             on the original application and contained claims 1-13, all as                                        
             shown in Appendix 5 of this opinion.                                                                 
                                  Prosecution of reissue application                                              
                          48. Applicant filed reissue application 08/230,083 on                                   
             April 20, 1994 seeking to reissue U.S. Patent 5,105,731.                                             
                          49. Applicant presented original patent claims 1-13                                     
             along with new reissue application claims 14-16 for                                                  
             consideration.                                                                                       
                          50. Reissue application claim 15 has been canceled and                                  
             is not involved in the appeal.                                                                       
                          51. Reissue application claims 14 and 16 are before                                     
             the Board in the appeal.                                                                             
                          52. A copy of reissue application claims 14 and 16                                      
             appears in Appendix 6 of this opinion.                                                               
                          53. The examiner has rejected reissue application                                       
             claims 14 and 16 under 35 U.S.C. § 251 maintaining that the                                          
             claims seek to "recapture" subject matter surrendered in                                             
             obtaining allowance of the claims which appear in the patent                                         
             sought to be reissued.                                                                               
                          54. The Examiner based the rejection of claims 14 and                                   
             16 on the grounds that when faced in the original application                                        


                                                    - 11 -11                                                      



Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007