Ex Parte Tuman et al - Page 11



          Appeal No. 2005-1988                                                         
          Application No. 09/822,651                                                   

          circumferential surface of the die wheel through the pores of the            
          pile woven or knit cloth to embed the pile woven or knit cloth in            
          the molten resin and to fill the hook-element-forming cavities to            
          form hook elements.  See column 4, lines 26-48.                              
               In view of the above disclosure of Wessels, it is clear that            
          one embodiment teaches the use of pressure (pressing force) in               
          attaching the molten resin to the pile woven or knit cloth.                  
          Hence, we agree with the examiner’s position on this issue.                  
          Appellants have not explained how this pressing force is                     
          different such that the polymeric material of Wessels would not              
          be fused to a first major side of the web.                                   
               On page 11 of the brief, appellants argue that “fused to                
          first major side of the web” cannot include encapsulation of the             
          entire web as asserted by the examiner.  We are not convinced by             
          this argument.  Whether or not the molten resin of Wessels is                
          fused to a first side, as well as a second side, still provides              
          that the molten resin is fused to a first major side of the web.             
          As such, we agree with the examiner’s statement made at the                  
          bottom of page 10 and at the top of page 11 of the answer in this            
          regard.                                                                      
               In view of the above, we affirm the rejection of claims 21,             
          40 and 48.                                                                   

               With respect to claims 23, 42-48, 50-53, and 55, beginning              
                                         -11-                                          




Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007