Ex Parte Harnish - Page 5




              Appeal No. 2005-2297                                                                 Παγε 5                                       
              Application No. 10/143,209                                                                                                        


              concerned with web material alignment and maintenance of the central line of a web                                                
              material so that the difference between the length of the generatrices of the side edges                                          
              and the central line of the web material is very small.                                                                           
                     We agree with the appellant that Wessman does not describe an adjustable web                                               
              folding system which adjust the position of the folding detour based on the sensing of a                                          
              physical characteristic of the web.  Instead, the Wessman sensors measure the                                                     
              presence of the edges of the web indicative of the alignment of the web.  Based on this                                           
              measurement, the guide roll 3 of the detour 20 is adjusted so as to adjust the position of                                        
              the web so as to align the edges of the web (col 1, lines 33 to 34; col. 4, line 51 to col. 5,                                    
              line 5).   Therefore, we will not sustain the examiner’s rejection of claim 1 and claims 2                                        
              to 9, 11, and 16 dependent thereon.                                                                                               
                     Claim 17 recites that there is a first force sensor for measuring the first force on                                       
              the web substrate, a second force sensor that measures a second force on the web                                                  
              substrate and the first and second force forces are compared to produce a resultant                                               
              force.  The folding detour is adjusted in relation to the resultant force.  In regard to the                                      
              recitations in claim 17, the examiner states:                                                                                     
                     . . . The web detour 20 is adjusted by device 13 due to the magnitude of a                                                 
                     resultant force signal generated by regulating device (not shown; see                                                      
                     column 4, lines 51 to 61).  The resultant force signal is a comparative                                                    
                     measurement of tension in the web 1 (i.e. if the tension in one edge of the                                                
                     web is greater than the other then only one sensor 12 will generate a                                                      
                     signal) [answer at page 3].                                                                                                


















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007