Ex Parte TONNA et al - Page 12



         Appeal No. 2006-0259                                                                       
         Application No. 09/220,462                                                                 

         of structural members, to simplify the assembly adjustment, and                            
         to decrease the weight of the overall device, as well as to                                
         prevent slippage due to slack of the drive belt.  As shown in                              
         figure 2, linear motor 20 is installed horizontally on the car 1,                          
         where upper rope 10a is positioned (page 6).                                               
              From the disclosure of Yoshinobu, we find that Yoshinobu                              
         replaces the motor located on top of the car with a linear motor                           
         mounted in the rope area.  Turning to Aulanko, we make reference                           
         to our findings, supra, as to the teachings and suggestions of                             
         the reference.  We additionally find from our review of Aulanko                            
         (col. 1, lines 24-26) that a previously known technique was to                             
         use a linear motor as the hoisting motor.  Aulanko discloses                               
         (col. 2, lines 29-32) that “[a]s compared to a linear motor, the                           
         motor of the invention, when used as an elevator motor, provides                           
         the advantage that it makes it unnecessary to build a rotor or                             
         stator extending over the whole length of the elevator shaft.”                             
         As we stated, supra, although Aulanko is directed to the motor                             
         for hoisting the elevator, from the disclosure of Aulanko that                             
         “[a]s compared with motors constructed according to previously                             
         known technology, the elevator machinery (and motor) of the                                
         invention is very flat.  It can therefore be installed in many                             
         places in an elevator system where previously known motors are                             
                                        12                                                          











Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007